UserWiki:ShadowRaiden

Hello, I’m ShadowRaiden, but you can call me (and tbh I’d prefer it) Scarlet! You can often find me replacing poor quality infobox images. Ideologically speaking, revolutionary anti-vanguardist nationalistic democratic socialist sums up my beliefs very well You can find my exact beliefs on my self insert



Short Overview of my Beliefs
Again, most are on my PCBA page. Go there for a full overview.

Economics

 * [[File:Guildsoc.png]] Guild-Organized Economy


 * [[File:Cooperative Socialism.png]] Cooperative Economics


 * [[File:Marketsoc.png]] Democratic Economics


 * [[File:Socgeo.png]] Land Value Tax
 * [[File:Anti-Elitism.png]] Anti-Rent


 * [[File:Distributist.png]] Widespread Ownership of Land


 * [[File:Welf.png]] Welfarism (but if you’re given the opportunity to work yet refuse it, you’re not getting welfare)
 * [[File:Welf.png]] Progressive Tax
 * [[File:Lukash.png]] Social Parasite Tax (basically those able to work yet refuse to do so will have to pay)


 * [[File:Keynes.png]] Mixed Market Economy


 * [[File:Regulationism.png]] Economic Regulationism


 * [[File:Libsoc.png]] Decentralized Economics (somewhat, the central government would still have a significant share, but so would local and state governments)


 * [[File:Libms.png]] Independent Cooperatives


 * [[File:NatProg.png]] Trust Busting
 * [[File:Trustbust.png]] Anti-Billionaire (yes billionaires shouldn’t exist in any capacity. There will be a wealth cap somewhere between 100-500 million)
 * [[File:Welf.png]] Wealth Redistribution
 * [[File:Distributist.png]] Pro-Small Business
 * [[File:Cooperative Socialism.png]] Pro-Cooperative

Social

 * [[File:Progconf.png]] Progressive Conservatism


 * [[File:SocFem.png]] Feminism (only 1st and 2nd waves)


 * [[File:AntiRacism.png]] Anti-Racism


 * [[File:Intercult.png]] Interculturalism (broadly speaking)
 * [[File:Native.png]] Cultural Autonomy (for native minorities)

Philosophical

 * [[File:Paternalism.png]] Paternalism


 * [[File:Community.png]] Communitarianism
 * [[File:AntiIndiv.png]] Anti-Individualism
 * [[File:DvRestrictive.png]] Anti-Permissive Society


 * [[File:Utility.png]] Utilitarianism


 * [[File:Humanismpix.png]] Humanism


 * [[File:Virtue ethics icon.png]] Virtue Ethics


 * [[File:Moral.png]] Moralism

Foreign

 * [[File:Nation.png]] Nationalism
 * [[File:Civnat.png]] Civic Nationalism
 * [[File:Leftnat.png]] Left-Wing Nationalism


 * [[File:Antiwest.png]] Anti-NATO
 * [[File:AmericanNat.png]] NATO Dissolution


 * [[File:Antieast.png]] Anti-Easternism (although not as much as the above)


 * [[File:Euroscept.png]] Euroscepticism


 * [[File:Protect.png]] Protectionism (tariffs depend on both labor conditions of and how influential said country is)


 * [[File:Antiimp.png]] Non-Interventionism/Anti-Imperialism


 * [[File:Pac.png]] Pacifism
 * [[File:Humanismpix.png]] Nuclear Weapon Disarmament
 * [[File:AntiMil.png]] Anti-Militarism


 * [[File:Globnat.png]] Alter-Globalization (regarding foreign policy)


 * [[File:Cball-Palestine.png]] Pro-Palestine
 * [[File:Secular.png]] Anti-Hamas
 * [[File:Antizion.png]] Anti-Zionism


 * [[File:Cball-Somaliland.png]] Somaliland Recognition


 * [[File:Cball-Ukraine.png]] Neutral, leaning towards Ukraine
 * [[File:Cball-Donetsk.png]] [[File:Cball-Lugansk.png]] Referendums on who to join in the Donbass Republics [[File:Cball-Russia.png]] [[File:Cball-Ukraine.png]]
 * [[File:AntiMil.png]] Anti-War
 * [[File:Cball-Crimea.png]] Crimean Unification with Russia [[File:Cball-Russia.png]]


 * [[File:Cball-China.png]] Two-State Solution [[File:Cball-Taiwan.png]]


 * [[File:Pan-Koreanism.png]] Peaceful Reunification of Korea (non-aligned and with both governments out of the question, through peaceful negotiation or revolution) [[File:Antiwest.png]] [[File:Antieast.png]]


 * [[File:Cball-Kosovo.png]] [[File:Cball-Albania.png]] Kosovar-Albanian Unification (except for [[File:Cball-Serbia.png]] Serb-majority areas who should join Serbia)


 * [[File:Demcon.png]] Pro-Kurdish Independence
 * [[File:Cball-Syria.png]] Pro-Assad (in the rest of Syria)


 * [[File:Cball-Artsakh.png]] Pro-Artsakh (Reunification with Armenia) [[File:Cball-Armenia.png]]


 * [[File:Cball-Abkhazia.png]] [[File:Cball-SouthOssetia.png]] Akhaz-South Ossetian autonomy within Georgia, or independence but non-aligned [[File:Cball-Georgia.png]]


 * [[File:Cball-Transnistria.png]] Transnistrian Autonomy [[File:Cball-Moldova.png]]

Government

 * [[File:Soc-h.png]] Revolutionary Socialism
 * [[File:Anti-Reform.png]] Anti-Reformism/Anti-Electoralism
 * [[File:DefDem.png]] [[File:Authdem.png]] Illiberal Democracy (initially post-revolution, in already developed countries)
 * [[File:Socauth.png]] [[File:Authdem.png]] Authoritarian Democracy (initially post-revolution, in undeveloped countries)
 * [[File:Ghandi.png]] Bloodless Revolution
 * [[File:Insurrectionary Anarchism.png]] Insurrection (if all other options fail)


 * [[File:Fed.png]] Federalism


 * [[File:Demsocstar.png]] Democratic Socialism (except for reformism)
 * [[File:Socauth.png]] Social Authoritarianism (in hard times)


 * [[File:Secular.png]] Secularism


 * [[File:Leftpop-0.png]] Left-Wing Populism


 * [[File:DefDem.png]] Defensive Democracy


 * [[File:Nooc.png]] Noocracy


 * [[File:Merit.png]] Meritocracy


 * [[File:Technocracy.png]] Technocracy
 * [[File:Neotech.png]] Technocratic Democracy

Ideological Evolution
->  ->  ->      ->    ->     ->

Stage 1: Neocon
I was brainwashed by western media and the notion that American intervention was a force of good, supported neo-classical economics, liberal hawk, oh and I was big on Reagan, Israel, and Pinochet. Oh and I unironically thought that PragerU was a good source. If you think this is the best/least bad stage of mine in any way whatsoever, please stfu.

Phase 2: National Liberal
I was wondering why America was so hated, since I loved my nation and wanted it to be loved as well. I then became more open to the reality of NATO and their crimes. I couldn’t bear some of the things I saw. I thought we were a force of justice. I felt I was lied to. I later embraced non-interventionism. I stopped supporting Pinochet. But this stage was still pretty bad. Neoclassical economics, still saw NATO as a lesser evil despite turning more against them, and supported countries like Israel and South Korea. But ultimately at least I was able to escape the cringe that was being a liberal hawk. Socially speaking I was conservative leaning, but with some progressive takes, mainly on LGBT and immigration. But I did base a lot of my ideals on SJW cringe compilations. That too was cringe

Phase 3: Moving Away From Neoclassical Economics
In a sense, this set a framework for my shift to the left. I was looking at Europe and was inspired by them, and how they built such prosperous countries. But I was still very much anti-EU and skeptical of all forms of leftism. Same social views as above

Stage 4: SocDem
I did call myself a “DemSoc” and did somewhat support worker self management but wasn’t very educated on that part either, though saw the concept was cool, but mostly I wanted social policies that benefitted the working class, wanted free healthcare and education, socialization of big businesses and major industries, trust busting, opposed billionaires, typical socdem things although somewhat masquerading as a socialist. But I still liked some socialists, mainly Tito, Kadar, Ho Chi Minh, and (somewhat) Castro (but supported the Cuban protests of 2021 as well although with some suspicion involving America’s role). Socially speaking I was center-progressive (pro-LGBT (but skeptical of some things), near-Laicist, supported eased legal immigration, but still had some conservative views, saw that some traditions are important, and was pro-life). I was skeptical of more radical progressive movements (but saw them as rightist psyops as well). And foreign policy speaking I was a nationalist and non-interventionist

Stage 5: “Old Left”
Honestly this one was rather cancerous, mainly the severe misusage of the term.

Basically after dealing with leftist idpol, I did start becoming more conservative in response to that. It was alright at first but it started to become pretty bad, and the breaking point was this next stage:

Phase 6: Abandoning Socialism
This phase was just outright awful. I was brainwashed by a certain fascist whom I will not name, and shittier experiences with liberal/progressive users made me an easier target for said radicalization. If not for a few irl factors things could have gone much, much worse. Needless to say, I’m glad I escaped this stage and this is a reminder to never abandon your socialist pride.

Phase 7: Return to Socialism
I felt awful on a personal level around the end of the previous stage, I couldn’t handle it, said feelings had a ton of unrelated factors, but feeling ashamed of betraying my own values was one of the factors. I have returned to socialism at last. Now you’d think this is a full circle ending, being a left-nationalist democratic socialist. But there are some differences. One is me being slightly more conservative, another is me favoring revolution over reform, yet another one is me being a genuine democratic socialist instead of a  social democrat pretending to be a demsoc. And lastly and most importantly, I began reading theory. I believe I’ll permanently settle here

Ideological Beliefs of People I Know
Father - /

He is pretty fiscally conservative, and socially speaking he is moderate, supporting things like LGBT rights and abortion rights, while being critical of more modern progressive movements, especially their support for Islam, which he opposes. Foreign policy wise, he is non-interventionist but still sympathetic to NATO, especially after the War in Ukraine started.

Mother - /

She has fairly similar beliefs to the one above, but does give in to the whole “cultural Marxism” thing and is further culturally right on some issues. She does support Trump, but doesn’t care about some of his social views, mainly on abortion or religion, and dislikes his climate change denial

A Hypothetical United Front Following My Ideas
Name: National People’s Front

Democratic People’s Solidarity Party

 * [[File:Guildsoc.png]] Guild Socialism
 * [[File:Demsocstar.png]] Democratic Socialism
 * [[File:Soc-h.png]] Revolutionary Socialism
 * [[File:Marketsoc.png]] Market Socialism
 * [[File:Leftnat.png]] Left-Wing Nationalism
 * [[File:Leftpop-0.png]] Left-Wing Populism
 * [[File:Progconf.png]] Progressive Conservatism

Libertarian Party

 * [[File:Natlib.png]] National Libertarianism (excluding capitalism and conservatism)
 * [[File:Libsoc.png]] Libertarian Socialism
 * [[File:Libms.png]] Libertarian Market Socialism
 * [[File:Distlib.png]] Distributist Libertarianism
 * [[File:Geobert.png]] Geo-Libertarianism

Labor Party

 * [[File:Long.png]] Longism
 * [[File:Distributist.png]] Distributism
 * [[File:Socgeo.png]] Social Georgism
 * [[File:Socnat.png]] Social Nationalism

Who I’d Vote For In US Presidential Elections
Note that in a sizable amount of them especially 1948-2012, I pick the lesser evil, it doesn’t mean I like him

1788 - George Washington

1792 - George Washington

1796 - Thomas Jefferson

1800 - Thomas Jefferson

1804 - Thomas Jefferson

1808 - James Madison

1812 - James Madison

1816 - James Monroe

1820 - James Monroe

1824 - John Quincy Adams

1828 - John Quincy Adams

1832 - Henry Clay

1836 - William Henry Harrison

1840 - William Henry Harrison

1844 - Henry Clay

1848 - Zachary Taylor

1852 - Winfield Scott

1856 - John C. Fremont

1860 - Abraham Lincoln

1864 - Abraham Lincoln

1868 - Ulysses S. Grant

1872 - Ulysses S. Grant

1876 - Rutherford B. Hayes

1880 - James A. Garfield

1884 - James G. Blaine

1888 - Benjamin Harrison

1892 - Benjamin Harrison

1896 - William Jennings Bryan

1900 - William Jennings Bryan

1904 - Theodore Roosevelt

1908 - William Howard Taft

1912 - Theodore Roosevelt

1916 - Charles Evans Hughes

1920 - Warren G. Harding

1924 - Robert M. La Follette

1928 - Al Smith

1932 - Franklin D. Roosevelt

1936 - Franklin D. Roosevelt

1940 - Franklin D. Roosevelt

1944 - Franklin D. Roosevelt

1948 - Harry Truman

1952 - Dwight Eisenhower

1956 - Dwight Eisenhower

1960 - John F. Kennedy

1964 - Lyndon B. Johnson

1968 - Hubert Humphrey

1972 - George McGovern

1976 - Gerald Ford

1980 - Jimmy Carter

1984 - Walter Mondale

1988 - Michael Dukakis

1992 - Ross Perot

1996 - Ross Perot

2000 - Al Gore

2004 - John Kerry

2008 - Barack Obama

2012 - Barack Obama

2016 - Mike Maturen (ASP)

2020 - Brian Carrol (ASP)

DozenValues
78.5 - 21.5% (Socialist)

62.5% - 37.5% (Regulated)

39.6% - 60.4% (Dispersed)

59.7% - 40.3% (Lenient)

50.0% - 50.0% (Normative)

54.2% - 45.8% (Conventional)

Closest Match: Guild Socialism

Next matches: De Leonism,   Religious Socialism

Worst results: Fordism,  Monarcho-Capitalism,  Timocracy

LeftValues
76.5% - 23.5% (Very Revolutionary)

75.0% - 25.0% (Scientific)

30.0% - 70.0% (Decentralist)

23.2% - 78.8% (Very Nationalist)

21.2% - 78.8% (Very Unionist)

41.7% - 58.3% (Neutral)

61.8% - 38.4% (Conservative)

Closest Match: Left-Wing Nationalism

Next Matches: Anarcho-Communism (95.2%),  Eco-Anarchism (89.3%),  Council Communism (85.7%),  Centrist Marxism (76.5%),  Orthodox Marxism (59.2%),  Eco-Marxism (53.3%),  Market Anarchism (52.5%),  Utopian Socialism (28.4%),  Left Communism (27.2%),  Marxism-Leninism (25.9%),  Democratic Socialism (12.7%),  Social Democracy (0%)

NewValues
72.7% - 27.3% (Social)

72.6% - 27.4% (Patriotic)

59.3% - 40.7% (Moderate)

45.9% - 54.1% (Neutral)

Closest result:  Minarcho-Titoism (what?)

Positive
Anti-Capitalism - capitalism is an economic system based on greed, exploitation, and repressing the workers

Anti-Social Democracy - you hate socdem because it’s “leftist”, I hate it because it’s capitalist, we are not the same.

Anti-Neoliberalism - Neoliberalism is an imperialist, globalist, and capitalist ideology

Anti-Austerity - all fiscal conservatives conserve is greed and the rich.

Anti-Libertarianism - libertarians explaining how unrestrained corporate greed makes things cheaper:

Anti-Racism - all races are created equal

Anti-Xenophobia - nobody should be treated differently for their race, ethnicity, or culture, even if for the latter they should learn ours through cross cultural communication. Likewise a nation is based off of common customs or values, not ethnicity or race

Anti-Colonialism - colonialism is an oppressive system

Anti-Interventionism - what other countries do is not our business

Anti-Porn - Pornography and prostitution are in no way empowering. They are a moral and societal evil, often exploitative, and a product of individualist degeneracy

Anti-Atlanticism - the west and NATO as a geopolitical entity has destroyed so many countries. As much as I dislike the two powers, Russia and China have been less destructive abroad, and there’s a reason why third world countries are turning towards the two

Euroscepticism - I’m not against the fundamental idea of the EU, but everything about it’s current state, from the ever increasing centralization, to the liberalism (both social and economic), to meddling in the affairs of other countries (ex: Poland, Hungary, and Belarus, even if I don’t particularly like them), and basically being an extension of NATO. Kill it with fire

Anti-Individualism - I don’t believe in this “permissively” and “live and let live” nonsense for the most part, and believe in a heavily family and community based society, even if I’m also against mass collectivism

Anti-Globalism - globalism is imperialism with a friendly face. I love my nation and will do anything to improve it for the better. Deal with it.

Anti-Idpol - whether it’s intersectional idpol or supremacist idpol, it has been disastrous and is a form of tribalism.

Left-Wing Anti-Communism - Marxism-Leninism is one of the things that make leftism look bad. But cool it with the succdem tendencies

Anti-Zionism - Israel is a false ally of ours

Anti-Reformism - reformism is a failed system which corrupts one, and serves to serve the establishment. It’s clear that revolution is the only way

Trust-Busting - billionaires and megacorp shouldn’t even exist. I support a small business based economy

Anti-Fascism - fascism is tyranny and injustice in one ideology. However, Antifa is cringg

Anti-Dengism - China is a state capitalist country which is also becoming more authoritarian than necessary, even if a strong hand is needed to control a nation of 1.4 billion people. “Um ackshually those are the people’s Amazon warehouses, the people’s billionaires, the people’s landlords” 🤓🤓🤓, Dengists are just neoliberals who hate the west.

Anti-Stalinism - Stalin was another state capitalist. Workers still toiled in wage labor, and formerly private assets didn’t go in the hands of the workers, but became state owned (some things should be nationalized but still), and the workers were denied the full fruit of their labor, but instead of the employer, it was the state. Even the achievements came with deep consequences.

Anti-Putinism - Crimea is Russia, but Putin is still a corrupt imperialist rightoid. Idk why some leftists support him

Neutral
Anti-Conservatism - while I acknowledge that some traditions are detrimental, the beneficial ones must be kept

Anti-Progressivism - I hate the whole “woke” stereotype as shown on the PCB interpretation, and believe that some traditions are important, but progress is still needed and some traditions are detrimental

Anti-Easternism - I oppose the governments of Russia and China, and believe that they too are imperialistic (nowhere near the level of the west but still), but the amount of you that tend to be Atlanticists is concerning at best and outright disgusting at worst

Anti-Communism - Marxism-Leninism and State Socialism are cringe, but a lot of you tend to be capitalists as well. Besides, people like Stalin are state capitalists, when will you realize this?

Anti-Monarchism - monarchism is generally cringe but if some countries want to keep it due to it being tradition, they can

Anti-Abortion - I’m you on a moral level, and think that advertisement, as well as 2nd and 3rd trimester abortions should be illegal, but I also fear underground/out of state abortions if you’re implemented without significant pro-family programs

Anti-Isolationism - while I oppose getting involved in most world affairs and oppose defense/military alliances and want to put my nation first, full blown isolationism is bad

Anti-Americanism - the government is shit, yes. But I love my nation and will do whatever it takes to improve it

Negative
Anti-Socialism - while socialism may not be perfect, and planned economies are cringe, it is the best system to defend workers rights

Anti-Nationalism - the nation defines who you are as people and creates a sense of unity and bonds amongst people. It’s natural to love your nation and culture

Anti-Authoritarianism - I’ll tread where I please. In all seriousness though, while I understand some of your concerns, some dictators are good and less auth doesn’t mean less bad

Anti-Revisionism - some revisionists like Khrushchev, Deng, and Gorbachev were bad, but hardline ML is almost as cancerous and ruined the name of socialism

Anti-Third Worldism - the third world should be able to prosper without either superpower budging into their business, even if they could learn some forms of western values while also staying strong to their own

Anti-Environmentalism - the environment is important and must be protected

Anti-LGBT - I hate pride parades, flamboyance, and the LGBT movement, but hating on ordinary LGBT people is cringe, they too are human and deserve respect

Economic
1: I believe in a system based off of worker guilds and cooperatives which function within a market economy, but with some decentral planning (+1)


 * I support cooperatives but they shouldn’t be a majority/the state should play a bigger role but not the sole role (+0.5)


 * I support a command economy and/or I firmly believe in the traditional business model (0)

2: I support trust busting to ensure fair competition, and believe that big businesses should be broken up into smaller cooperatives whenever possible (+1)


 * Corporate usury should be punished and smaller companies should be given a headstart, but big businesses should still exist (+0.5)


 * Big corporations should face little to no regulations (0)

3: I support a welfare state, however those that have the opportunity to work, yet reject said opportunity, shouldn’t be given welfare (+1)


 * Even the lazy should be given welfare/only the employed should be given welfare no matter what (+0.5)


 * There shouldn’t be a welfare state (0)

4: I support progressive taxation (+1)


 * I support flat taxation (+0.5)


 * I support regressive taxation/no taxation (0)

5: I support fair trade and moderate tariffs (+1)


 * I support low/high tariffs (+0.5)


 * I support autarky or free trade (+0)

6: landlords shouldn’t exist, and land should be subsidized (+1)


 * Landlords can exist but there would be LVT and rent control (+0.5)


 * Rent should be permitted (+0)

7: Billionaires should not exist, millionaires should be under tight state control, and there should be a hard wealth cap. All exploitative rich should be imprisoned or if bad enough, executed (+1)


 * Billionaires can exist but they must pay their fair share of taxes (+0.5)


 * Billionaires should be able to get away with whatever they want and influence society (0)

8: healthcare is a human right, and there should be a single payer system covering health insurance. However those who inflicted their pain onto themselves (drinkers, smokers, over-eaters, the unvaccinated) should have to pay for anything that’s a factor of such as a consequence for not looking after their wellbeing (+1)


 * Even those that had their pain self inflicted should have free healthcare/I support a multi-payer system (+0.5)


 * Healthcare should be privatized (0)

9: although not state capitalism, state socialism is an overbureaucratic system that puts the power in the hands of a few, masquerading as a “socialist state” or “people’s democracy”. Even if it means remaining as an agrarian society we should avoid state socialism, it’s also why socialism has this awful reputation of being an overbureaucratic system (+1)


 * State socialism is state capitalism/state socialism is only good as a short term goal (+0.5)


 * State socialism is ideal/all socialism is state socialism (0)

10: banks should be mutually owned and credit unions, but under a banking guild or some form of government control (albeit not extreme) to ensure stability (+1)


 * The state should own the banks but give those using said bank a voice/bankers can exist but they must be regulated/mutually owned banks shouldn’t have any state regulations (+0.5)


 * Bankers should be dominant (0)

Government
1: Revolution > reform, always. More specifically, bloodless revolution (+1)


 * I support bloody revolution/I support reformism as a first attempt but would still consider revolution even in democratic societies (+0.5)


 * I support reformism no matter what/revolution should be limited to dictatorships (0)

2: Representatives become isolated from the wants and needs from the people, and as such, are overall bad. However there should be polls and referendums on some issues that can be held on any level (+1)


 * Representatives can be good but the system would need changed (+0.5)


 * Representatives are good as is (0)

3: I support federalism (+1)


 * I support confederalism or a more centralized system (+0.5)


 * I support anarchism/hyper unitarism (0)

4: We should try to ensure direct decision making by the people as much as possible, but with some small scale state influence (+1)


 * The state should play a bigger or smaller role but said direct decision making should be allowed/there should still be some state influence (+0.5)


 * There should be no state influence or there shouldn’t be any form of direct democracy (0)

5: a democratic society is ideal, but we must put other things first, such as economic prosperity and living standards of the people. Sometimes authoritarianism can be necessary (+1)


 * I am more moderate/extreme, but support your general message (+0.5)


 * I would implement democracy even if the people have poor living conditions/all democracy is bad/authoritarianism is never necessary (0)

6: I support proportional representation and ranked choice voting (+1)


 * I support one but not the other (+0.5)


 * I support both a system that disregards regional popularity, and I support “first past the post” (0)

7: I support a loose party system (+1)


 * I am slightly more pro-partisan/support the abolition of political parties (+0.5)


 * I support a party state/vanguard party (0)

8: I oppose conscription unless we are being attacked and can’t defend ourselves as is, and believe it is evil to force one into a military career (+1)


 * Even if we are being attacked, we shouldn’t conscript (+0.5)


 * I support conscription always and/or during offensive wars (0)

9: we need a police force that’s both strong enough to efficiently handle crime, but not so strong that it treads on basic freedoms (+1)


 * I’m more extreme on either end, but support your general message (+0.5)


 * I support a police state/defund or abolish the police (0)

10: Left Unity > Auth/Lib Unity (+1)


 * I’m a centrist on such matter (+0.5)


 * Auth/Lib/Right Unity > Left Unity (0)

Foreign
1: I am neutral on bloc politics and see both NATO and Russia/China as bad (but if you’re ever so slightly leaning towards the east but still oppose them, you can still get one point) (+1)


 * I’m against both blocs, but the west is ever so slightly a lesser evil, but they’re still bad/I’m critical but supportive of the east (+0.5)


 * I uncritically support the east/I support the west, critically or not (0)

2: what other countries do is not our business, and we should only intervene if we were attacked first or if there is a large scale genocide. If journalists and activists are suppressed half way across the world, not our problem. (+1)


 * Even if there’s a genocide, we shouldn’t intervene (+0.5)


 * I support interventionism no matter what (0)

3: I am a nationalist and will do whatever to support my nation as a whole, even if the government is bad (+1)


 * I am a patriot, but not a nationalist (+0.5)


 * I am an ultranationalist/I am unpatriotic (0)

4: despite being a nationalist, I support international solidarity and cooperation in necessary areas such as climate change (+1)


 * I go further in cooperation (+0.5)


 * I refuse to cooperate on anything (0)

5: I believe in a balanced solution on immigration (+1)


 * I lean one way, but am not extreme (+0.5)


 * We should let literally anyone in/we should let nobody in (0)

6: The National Special Intelligence Service should not conduct any operations outside of the country’s borders, unless there’s undeniable evidence there is a planned terrorist attack (+1)


 * Even if there’s a terror attack planned against us, it must remain purely domestic (+0.5)


 * It should interfere with other nations (0)

7: We should not have any military bases abroad (+1)


 * We should have military bases abroad, but minimize usage of said base and how many bases there are (+0.5)


 * We should actively use military based abroad (0)

8: I’m alright with regional cooperation alliances, provided they aren’t militaristic and there is still a strong degree of independence (+1)


 * I am less concerned about independence but still oppose military alliances/we should reject any and all alliances (+0.5)


 * We should be in military alliances (0)

9: I’m against irredentism, however we should have strong cultural ties with land belonging to other countries populated with our culture and people (+1)


 * I could care less about cultural ties with said areas (+0.5)


 * I am an irredentist (0)

10: I support a pacifist foreign policy (+1)


 * I’m mixed between the two (+0.5)


 * I support a hawkish foreign policy/we should sanction other countries (0)

Social
1: I see both progress and tradition as important (+1)


 * I lean towards one or the other, but don’t completely disregard the opposite (+0.5)


 * I see no value in progress/tradition (0)

2: a nation is built off of common traditions and values, not skin color (+1)


 * I consider my country to be one of a certain race/ethnicity, but won’t discriminate against other races or ethnicities in my country (+0.5)


 * We should persecute other races or ethnicities (0)

3: men and women must be equal, and we shouldn’t subscribe to strict gender roles (+1)


 * Men and women should be equal, but gender roles should remain (+0.5)


 * I oppose gender equality (0)

4: I would legalize same sex marriage/civil unions, and I oppose both homophobia and flamboyance (+1)


 * No form of same sex union should be recognized, but they shouldn’t be persecuted for who they are/I’m a little more liberal on the issue, but the modern pride movement goes too far (+0.5)


 * I support persecution of LGBT people/I support the LGBT movement (0)

5: Transitioning should be legal although tightly regulated, but I am a transmedicalist, and similar to above I oppose pride (+1)


 * I am a bit more liberal on the topic, but support your general message (+0.5)


 * Transitioning is this quirky/fun thing (or I tolerate said POV)/you don’t need dysphoria to be trans/it should be illegal regardless (0)

6: I support a communitarian outlook on society (+1)


 * I support mass collectivism/I am more moderate on the issue (+0.5)


 * I am an individualist (0)

7: climate change is a real and urgent problem and should be addressed immediately via nuclear and eventually green energy, although we should only pressure developed countries to take part in such (+1)


 * I’m anti-nuclear energy and/or even underdeveloped countries should be pressured (+0.5)


 * Climate change is fake/exaggerated or I’m a dark green environmentalist (0)

8: I support secularism, but acknowledge that some religious values can be good, but not to the point of being a confessionalist (+1)


 * I am a Religious Democrat or a Laicist (+0.5)


 * I am a Theocrat/State Atheist (0)

9: Abortion is morally wrong, but we also need to address socioeconomic conditions, and contraception should be available (+1)


 * Abortion is morally wrong but it should be legal for the first 2 trimesters (+0.5)


 * There is nothing morally wrong with abortion/it should be legal for all three trimesters/even if the mother or baby will die, it should be illegal/I will ignore socioeconomic conditions (0)

10: I support technological advancement, and won’t mind using technology to enhance biology (+1)


 * I don’t support using technology to enhance biology, but overall support technological advancement (+0.5)


 * We should regress technologically speaking/technology should take over every single workplace /I support posthumanism (0)

Geopolitics
1: Disband NATO. (+1)


 * Don’t disband it, but it should be less interventionist and hegemonic (+0.5)


 * NATO is good as is (0)


 * NATO doesn’t go far enough (-1)

2: I’m not against the fundamental idea of the EU, but almost everything about the current EU is bad (+1)


 * I don’t even support the concept/I’m more moderate on the issue than you (+0.5)


 * I support the EU as is (0)

3: Crimea is Russia, and Ukraine isn’t this bastion of democracy, but I oppose the war in Ukraine. In the end, the War in Ukraine is a capitalist war. (+1)


 * Crimea is Ukraine, but I still see the Ukrainian government as heavily flawed (+0.5)


 * I support the invasion/I’m a diehard supporter of Ukraine (0)

4: I support a united, polycultural and secular Palestine (+1)


 * I support a two-state solution (+0.5)


 * I support Israel/Hamas (0)

5: Both sides are dogmatic when it comes to China. They are cringe and overly authoritarian state capitalist, but they aren’t this Nazi reincarnation. Nor are they this savior (+1)


 * I lean one way but don’t support the extremes (+0.5)


 * China is the modern day Nazi Germany/China is this socialist savior (0)

6: I support Kurdish independence, and Assad in the rest of Syria (+1)


 * I only support Kurdish independence/Assad (+0.5)


 * I support FSA/Turkey/ISIS (0)

7: Both Koreas are cringe, and there should be a non-aligned and non-Marxist socialist revolution (+1)


 * I lean towards one of the governments on the peninsula, even if I don’t like it/I support the status quo (+0.5)


 * Either of the two Koreas should take over the entirety of the peninsula (0)

8: I’m anti-NATO, but I also oppose the SCO/CSTO and the like, although not as bad as NATO (+1)


 * They should exist to counter NATO, but I don’t like the fundamental idea of it (+0.5)


 * I support them/I oppose it for pro-NATO reasons (0)

9: I oppose Lukashenko, but don’t want Belarus to fall to the EU. (+1)


 * I don’t like the EU, but it’s preferable to Lukashenko/I support Lukashenko (+0.5)


 * I support a pro-EU uprising in Belarus (0)

10: there needs to be an authoritarian, secular, and non-Marxist socialist government in Afghanistan (+1)


 * I support an authoritarian government that is communist or non-kleptocratic/non-jihadist (+0.5)


 * Democracy will work in Afghanistan’s current state/I support the previous Afghan government/I support the Taliban (0)

Total Scores

 * - 50/50
 * - 37/50
 * - 43/50

Quadrants
Left Unity - my quadrant, but has a Baizuo and Leftcom problem

Authoritarian Left - my 2nd quadrant, and other than Tankies and Dengists, based

LibLeft - kinda based, but has a Baizuo and AnCom problen

AuthCenter - some of it’s ideologies, such as Paternalistic Conservatism and  Social Authoritarianism are based, but most of it is cringe

Center - look, I appreciate you wanting to be moderate, but it just isn’t enough.

LibCenter - too lib civically, too right economically. I like Andrew Yang though

Authoritarian Right - I like Lee Kwan Yew and Kagame, but that’s it. Otherwise, cringe

Right Unity - basically LibRight without the good qualities, terminally and utterly cringe Neolibtards and Neocuckservatives

Libertarian Right - we like free speech, gun rights, non-interventionism, and decentralization, otherwise absolutely cringe laissez-faire

User Relations
Personality= NOTE: I am not adding an enemy section and quite frankly I think they should be banned to minimize drama

Friends
- great friend and very based ideology

Nekoqing - another great friend. However, your ideology is rather cringe nowadays

- same as DNY

Sykar - meh-cringish ideology, but great person. Fellow waifu enjouer

Immorxius - meh-basedish ideology, great person

IvarsBalodis - great friend and we share very similar beliefs, you indirectly got me into guildsoc

Apple - kinda based ideology, cool person. RIP

- basedish ideology and cool guy

TDRH - meh ideology (too economically moderate and I may be slightly more culturally right and auth than you) but cool person

SamKibGuy - cool ideology and person, even if further left and more progressive than myself

GhostlySpear1 - great friend and we share a lot in common ideologically speaking. Same as Apple, RIP

- seems nice and is overall based ideologically speaking although more right wing on both factors

- based ideology and you seem cool

NotLibra - we talked a bit on discord and you’re cool, ok ideology

Glencoe13 - ok ideology, great person

CarbynSobek - cool ideology overall though more auth and left than myself, and you seem great

Friends but ideologically cringe
NazBolGANG12 - way too culturally right but cool person

- same as above

- way too authoritarian and right wing, but cool person

- way too socially progressive and pro-west, and not left enough on economics, but personally you’re cool. Also glad to see you’re embracing patriotism now vs a while back

- I disagree with most of what you believe in, but you’re a cool person

Idk you but you seem cool
Anglo-germanic socialist - relations have yet to develop but you seen cool and your ideology is rather based

Cheebow8 - you seem like a cool person and fellow pro-lifer, but overall cringe ideology

League of Nationsball - your ideology seems based albeit too extreme, and you seem cool

- eh ideology, but you seem nice

Marsis - ok ideology, but too libertarian and culturally liberal. And you seem nice

Melkor - bringe ideology but you seem nice

Note: this only reflects on ideologies. Even if your ideology is placed in a negative tier, I ultimately have nothing against you as an individual
 * -| Ideology=

Based (80-100)
(//) (100/100)- very similar beliefs to myself

(//) (98/100) - same as above but doesn’t fully embrace guilds

IvarsBalodis (//) (95/100) - also a very close ideological match

GhostlySpear1 (//) (95/100) - me but Islamic

Glencoe(// ) (80/100) - based although more libertarian and friendly to welfare capitalists than myself, but overall it’s something I can get by

(//) (80/100) - a more moderate version of myself, overall based

Kinda Based (60-79)
Duy (// (75/100) - based, but too liberal, reformist, and friendly to welfare capitalists

Apple (//) (70/100) - more moderate than myself but otherwise based

CarbynSobek (//) (70/100) - based for a ML

Neutral (40-59)
Sykar (//) (50/100) - culturally speaking you’re based even with a few disagreements and your economic model is good although a little moderate. But stop being interventionist and reformist. Barely escapes being cringish

Kinda Cringe (20-39)
Shrek (//) (21/100) - Hoxhaism and hardline ML is cringe

(//) (21/100) - same as above

(//) (32/100) - too liberal and pro-west (albeit at least not to the extent of before), and not left enough on economics. But has a few good points, though overall cringe

Nekoqing (//) (21/100) - ok yeah your ideology has degraded beyond any repair, becoming full Stalinite and supporting social imperialism as long as it was committed by Stalin. The rest of your ideology does not make up for the hardliner simping, statesoc economics, and civic views.

CynicalLibra (//) (30/100) - too far left and auth, and I don’t really buy this whole revprog thing, and Maoism is cringe, but you’re still fairly based for such and we both support revolution. But it’s possible you might pull a BPP and be one of the only good Maoists.

Want to be Added?
Request me to add an ideological relation here

Template: (//)

Glencoe(// )(i am pro-revolution by the way) CynicalLibra (//) (//) CarbynSobek (//)

Positive
Guild Socialism, Left-Wing Populism,  Left-Wing Nationalism, and  Eco-Socialism - my ideologies

Market Socialism - based but a lot of you are socdems.

Social Distributism - a good alternative to guildsoc if needed. Pro-coop, pro-small business, and small scale property ownership are all based

Progressive Conservatism - my social views

Federalism - my stance on government.

Positive Leaning
Libertarian Market Socialism - good but too libertarian

Social Authoritarianism - too authright, but you have based figures and actually get things done unlike socdem. Would incorporate some elements from this depending on the situation

Social Georgism - some of you are based and I support LVT, but a lot of you tend to be them.

Neutral
Classical Liberalism - was good for the time, but should stay in the past.

Liberal Socialism - it depends

Keynesianism - a mixed market economy is based but that’s it.

Negative Leaning
Nordic Model - can I commend you for being better than a lot of western countries? Yes. Does that change the fact that you’re capitalist, liberal, and often atlanticist? No.

Negative
Capitalism - greed, exploitation, unjust hierarchy. That’s all that needs said.

Marxism-Leninism - while you have some sporadic based moments you’re overall cringe and an overbureaucratic system who betrays other leftists

Favorite Quotes
Note that just because I list someone doesn’t necessarily mean I like them, even if it’s the case for most of them

“If Chile was the cradle of neoliberalism, it will also be its grave.“ - Gabriel Boric

“ The true soldier fights not because he hates what is in front of him, but because he loves what is behind him.” - G.K. Chesterton

“Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.” - Benjamin Franklin

Montana Territory
Sidney Edgerton (1864-1866)

Thomas Francis Meagher (acting) (1865-1866)

Green Clay Smith (1866-1869)

James Tufts (acting) (1869)

James Mitchell Ashley (1869-1870)

Wiley Scribner (acting) (1869-1870)

Benjamin F. Potts (1870-1883)

John Schuyler Crosby (1883-1884)

Benjamin Platt Carpenter (1884-1885)

Samuel Thomas Hauser (1885-1887)

Preston Leslie (1887-1889)

Benjamin F. White (1889)

State of Montana
Joseph Toole (1889-1893)

John E. Rickards (1893-1897)

Robert Burns Smith (1897-1901)

Joseph Toole (1901-1908)

Edwin Lee Norris (1908-1913)

Sam V. Stewart (1913-1921)

Joseph M. Dixon (1921-1925)

John E. Erickson (1925-1933)

Frank Henry Cooney (1933-1935)

Elmer Holt (1935-1937)

Roy E. Ayers (1937-1941)

Sam C. Ford (1941-1949)

John W. Bonner (1949-1953)

J. Hugo Aronson (1953-1961)

Donald Grant Nutter (1961-1962)

Tim Babcock (1962-1969)

Forrest H. Anderson (1969-1973)

Wip

North America
American Solidarity Party - my only complaint is that you are a bit too moderate economically, otherwise you’re everything I like.

New Democratic Party (kinda) - not really good but the best that Canada has to offer

Morena - Cardenismo, leftpop/leftnat, and non-interventionist? Based

Zapatista Army of National Liberation - I gained several inspirations from you, and also based fighting for indigenous rights and against neoliberals

Communist Party of Cuba - for all it’s faults, it improved Cuba. Keep resisting US imperialism! Viva Cuba!

People’s United Party based on your ideology, you seem decent although too economically moderate and religious for my likings

National Unity of Hope - the president from that party, Alvaro Colom, improved living conditions in Guatemala

Liberty and Refoundation - Manuel Zelaya improved Honduras

Sandinista Renovation Movement - the FSLN is good but Ortega ruined it. Left-wing nationalism is also based. You’re a bit too economically moderate though

Sandinista National Liberation Front (kinda) - based socialism, left nationalism, left populism, and anti-imperialism. I admire Augusto C. Sandino, like Nicaragua’s cooperative system, and Christian Socialism is an ideology I can get by. However, Ortega is a brute and should be removed. Remove him and you’ll be 100% positive

Democratic Revolutionary Party - improved Panama

South America
United Socialist Party of Venezuela (somewhat) - under Chavez, you were good but flaws, even if sanctions play just as much if not a bigger role for a poor economy, but Maduro is retarded and should be ousted from within

Colombia Humana - I have faith in you, please, defeat the rightoids in Colombia. Update: LETS GOOOOOO YOU WON

Citizen Revolution Movement - your ideology is very similar to mine and Rafael Correa was based.

Peru Libre - based socialism, nationalism, and pro-indigenous.

Movement for Socialism - greatly improved Bolivia, though removing term limits was a dick move on Evo’s part.

Guasu Front - for the one term this party was in power, it helped the poor of Paraguay and made housing and healthcare more accessible. Hopefully you end the Colorado Party’s monopoly over Paraguayan politics one day

Worker’s Party - corruption is an issue, but overall not bad and certainly preferable to Bolsonaro.

Broad Front - it did great service for Uruguay while in power, and the variety of different types of democratic leftists within this party is also something I’d do in one led by myself

Frente de Todos - same as the Worker’s Party, has a corruption problem, but overall based

Social Convergence (somewhat) - tbh I’m rather disappointed but still have hopes for you regarding environmentalism and economics, and you’re better than everyone else

Europe
Sadly a lot of European parties are either MLs, RightPops, Atlantards, or shitlibs, so don’t expect much here

Sinn Fein - too cuddly towards the EU, but this is still an overall based party, with it’s democracy, socialism, and Irish nationalism

Labour Factions - Labour overall is cringe, however not all of it is:


 * [[File:Corbynism-ball.png]] [[File:Demsocstar.png]] Hard Left - you’re the only saving grace of Labour and Britain as a whole, as you’re genuinely leftist, unlike the rest of Labour whom are closeted neolibs. But reformism won’t get you anywhere


 * [[File:Guildsoc.png]] Blue Labour - another based faction of Labour, I wish you were more popular, but still overall a force of good in Britain.

La France Insoumise - you have pretty good economic policies, and also have based ideas involving wanting to leave NATO, a pacifist foreign policy, and opposing the neoliberalism of the EU. What else can I say but gigachad?

Die Linke Factions - not big on this party as a whole but there is one faction that I like:


 * [[File:Wagenknecht.png]] Aufstehen - you have based ideas of democratic socialism, social policies, and anti-militarism and anti-NATO. A bit too Russophilic, otherwise based.

Asia and the Pacific
Japanese Communist Party - further left than myself, but still overall based. But become revolutionary

Progressive Party - same as above

People’s Action Party - one of the few capitalists I can respect

PDI-P - Pancasila and left nationalism is based, and Jokowi is a good president for the most part

Democratic Labor Party - too economically moderate and I hate how you tend to have your voters choose Liberal as a 2nd option, but overall not bad

Communist Party of India - you did good in Kerala and honestly speaking the INC is corrupt as hell so why should I support them?

People’s Mojahedin Organization of Iran - you’d do great for Iran, with your ideology of socialism and secularism

Syrian Arab Baath Party (somewhat) - based, but cool it with the corruption and pro-Putin sentiment (although the latter is kinda understandable)

Democratic Socialist Arab Ba'ath Party - the above but better

Democratic Union Party  - based ideology and I support Rojava and Kurdish independence. But rn is not a time to be this decentralized

Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaks) - become non aligned, and limit Greater Armenia to Armenia + Artsakh, but otherwise based market socialism and left nationalism

Parties I Despise
Note that this is for especially bad parties

North America
Republican Party

Democratic Party

Liberal Party of Canada

Valor

South America
United Socialist Party of Venezuela (Maduro Era)

Liberal Party

Europe
Tories

Labour (except for Corbyn and Blue Labour)

Volt

Alliance 90/The Greens

Serbian Progressive Party

United Russia

Asia-Pacific
Liberal Democratic Party of Japan

People’s Power Party

Worker’s Party of Korea

Chinese Communist Party

Democratic Progressive Party

Partai Berkaya

Liberal Party (Australia)

Bharatiya Jana Party

Combatant Clergy Association

Likud

AK Parti

Positive
American Solidarity Party - the only good party in this country, but I’m not so sure about the whole Catholic ethics thing, and you’re a bit moderate economically.

Negative
Basically every party here lmfao. Fr though lets get into the specifics:

Republican Party - economically terrible (and so far right on that factor they’d be unelectable in 80% of the world) and is full of neocons and/or climate change deniers, and even so a lot of you do give into rightist idpol.

Democratic Party - another neoliberal who gives into idpol (this time intersectional), and also is an imperialist. How so many self proclaimed “leftists” support you is astonishing.

Libertarians - at least an improvement from the previous two with your non-interventionism, but if you took power the US would be in economic crisis

Green Party - one of the least bad on this list, but still completely unhinged on social views

Democratic Socialists of America - same as above, not only that, but you have influences from welfare capitalism and support the Dems (so much for being socialist LMFAO)

Constitution Party - isolationism and federalism are good even then you take the former too far, but the rest is just no. Strict constitutionalism (even if it is needed to some degree), unhinged conservatism, borderline laissez-faire, cringe

Communist Party USA - yeah I’m not voting for MLs plus you all are feds

American Party of Labor - tolerating secession, supporting idpol, being friendly with the theocratic ideological spreading regime of Iran, and just the overall Marxist-Leninist and State Socialist ideology makes this cringe

Country Opinions
Note: this is about the country’s politics, not the people

Based, No Changes Needed
Bolivia

Good, but require a few tweaks
Zapatista Autonomous Rebel Municipalities

Cuba

Botswana

Namibia

Vietnam

Singapore

Indonesia

Ok, improve further
Mexico

Argentina

Rojava

Oman

Meh
Honduras

Nicaragua

Colombia

Peru

Chile

Pretty Bad
From here, revolution is needed

Hungary

Poland

Belarus

Taiwan

Philippines

Bad
Brazil

China

Australia

Revolution Needed, Fast…
Canada

USA (unfortunately)

Haiti

Venezuela

most EU states

Ukraine

Russia

Japan

South Korea

India

Raze the entire fucking system to the ground
Most of Africa

Afghanistan

Saudi Arabia

Israel

North Korea

Comments
Glencoe - add me CarbynSobek - Add me?

Will add both of you - You should probably update since I don't consider myself a Nazcap anymore

Marsis - looks pretty based over here, care to add me?


 * sure -

- Yo, wanna add my ideology?

- Update the relationship please, I dropped atlanticism (still pro-west but not to the extent I was).


 * will do (replying to both)