User Proposals

Explanation
Hello everyone Buni here. This page is the User Proposals page in the section below you can propose changes to the wiki and the council will discuss and then if discussed enough will vote on the changes proposed. You can propose a few different kinds of changes: Alternate Designs, Compass Positions, Council Structure, Deletion of Pages, Design Changes, Disambiguation Pages, Integrations, Mergers, New Pages, Power Transfer (from the council to a user for the purpose of writing a page), Redirects, Renaming, Replacing, Templates, and Variants. I will answer proposals with the results and delete the proposal and the result 2 weeks after to keep the page clean. Other council members may also answer, so users know who is a council member and who isn't here is the updated list:
 * [[File:Buni_council.png]] Buni
 * [[File:Inky_council.png]] Inky
 * [[FIle:Monkey_council.png]] Monkeysszz
 * [[File:Atzyn_council.png]] Atzyn
 * [[File:Nguyen_council.png]] Nguy
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao
 * [[File:Nyteulo_council.png]] Nyteulo
 * [[File:Compost_council.png]] Lord Compost
 * [[File:Froggers_council.png]] Founding Froggers (No editing wiki)

Your Proposals

 * Your site is missing information about the case of the "Small Government Conservatism" ideology/view. If possible, add it as an ideology, a variant, or at least an alias in another ideology. - ~Ameno94
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - just add it as an alias lol
 * I can add it as an alias, but please verify that it shouldn't be a variant (to libertarian conservatism, paleolibertarianism or other ideology), because sometimes such nonsenses is added as variants. But your answer to the suggestions at end is "lol". ~Ameno94
 * I propose we bring back Christian Communism and Trumpism [[File:Ion07.png]]
 * Why exactly those two? -Buni (talk) 22:44, 24 January 2023 (UTC)
 * [[File:Ion07.png]]: They're both relevant ideologies. Trumpism is very relevant in USA and Christian Communism is relevant in Russia.
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - This is not the determining factor for pages, otherwise any world leader could have its own page, and regardless of it both of these "ideologies" have no defined doctrine, and can be represented by other ideologies, in the case of trumpism right wing populism, and in the case of christian communism, christian socialism or national communism for zyuganov specifically.
 * [[File:Ion07.png]]: Socialism and Communism are two different ideologies and national communism has nothing to do with religion or conservatism
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - In the context of "christian communism" they are essentially the same thing, and im saying national communism represents Zyuganov well enough, removing the need for "christian communism"
 * [[File:Ion07.png]]: Then national communism should be called Zyuganovism instead. Either that, or it won't be a good replacement from Christian Communism


 * I propose to move this page to Community:User Proposals, as with other community pages -
 * No I put this page not there on purpose I put it here so it shows in the recent changes so it gets more attention. -Buni (talk) 22:44, 24 January 2023 (UTC)


 * I would propose an election of moderators: basically a few users propose themselves as candidates with their own ideas for the Wiki Page, and the other users vote the one that they prefer. In case people don't like how things may be runned for a certain period of time. ([[File:Omega.png]] Omega1065)
 * Listen I can tell you as someone who has gone through the mod applications document no one is quailified not a singel person is qualified enough. Out of 40 people in febuaray 3 got choosen and I was one of those 3. I am sorry to tell you but all mod matieral has left the community and holding any sort of election in this enviornemnt will just end up getting someone voted in who will most likely end up getting the wiki banned. -Buni (talk) 22:44, 24 January 2023 (UTC)


 * Bring back Stalinism as it was a very well-developed page - Am m
 * I hope all of you are aware this page simply isnt for wanting to bring back pages. Either way no we wont. We were fairly certain in our descison as we had consulted multiple leninists and marxist-leninists on the descision and it was pretty clear that Stalinism is just a period of Marxism-Leninism and that Marxism-Leninism in essence sprouted off of Stalinism to justify Stalinism (that is also the consesnsus in modern circles within the history profession) -Buni (talk) 22:54, 24 January 2023 (UTC)
 * Yes but this wiki, as stated on the main page, isn't supposed to be a serious database of ideologies - "...this wiki is a support base for Polcompball artists and casual browsers, not a...fact checked repository for information about political ideologies".
 * I am aware of this is is why this is a ball wiki still has the relationships, personality, all the infobox stuff etc. but we do want to be accurate in the ideologies we choose to be on the wiki since we are of the opinion that this would in the end help the subreddit artists more with creating better and more funny comics. -Buni (talk) 23:02, 24 January 2023 (UTC)


 * Remove [[file:Islamfash.png]] Islamic Fascism, make a new page called [[file:Grey-Wolves-icon-pcb.png]] Turkish Idealism -  (talk).
 * Jao already suggested this in the council lmao -Buni (talk) 08:35, 26 January 2023 (UTC)


 * Shouldn’t the Third way be merged into Neoliberalism seeing as we merged several variants of ML into the ML and Third way is a variant of Neoliberalism? also while we are on the subject are we going to make State Liberalism serious or keep as a joke ideology? if we are going to take it serious I can change it i already have plans on my computer.- glencoe
 * A reasonable and somewhat actually good suggestion I'll put this in the council fur discussion -Buni (talk) 08:35, 26 January 2023 (UTC)
 * Alright get back to me when its decided-glencoe


 * Remove entire post-right anarchism section on Avaritionism, they have no connection with this ideology. Since you allowed to use ideologies in sub-section in comics, it would allow to add any ideology at all as "canon". Also they leak in relations and influences of real ideologies. Duck-Citizen (talk) 09:09, 26 January 2023 (UTC)
 * I'll put this up to a vote seems sensible (and variants are allowed to be in relationships and influences) -Buni (talk) 02:12, 27 January 2023 (UTC)


 * Add [[File:Eshayism.png]] bah! - '''2x2Master ( [[File:Eshayism.png]] / [[File:Totalitarian.png]] / [[File:Nazbol.png]] / [[File:Gigachad.png]] / [[File:Antiquitism.png]] / [[File:Roblox.png]] / [[File:Minecraft.png]] / [[File:Fortnite.png]] / [[File:Klep.png]] / [[File:Psychopathy.png]] )
 * Nope. That's not a real ideology. -Buni (talk)
 * It is brah! You're talking mad itshay! 69x420Master (talk) 22:48, 27 January 2023 (UTC) 02:12, 27 January 2023 (UTC)


 * I already had sent this proposal to Buni before i knew this page existed but i feel like i should post it here. The ideology of Mh:polcompballanarchy:Getulism should be added to the main wiki, it has its own defined doctrine, just social authoritarianism doesn't cover it completely and also it was a very, very relevant ideology to brazil from the 1930's to the 1970's, really only relatively falling out of relevance due to the left leaving labourism for socialism with Lula, but it is still relevant to the political landscape and represented by theorists and parties today.
 * It is already in discussion no worries -Buni (talk) 02:12, 27 January 2023 (UTC)


 * It offers a purely cosmetic proposal rather than introducing something new, because I propose to make more legible captions on all images -
 * If you could clarify what you mean that would be great -Buni (talk) 02:12, 27 January 2023 (UTC)
 * In the sense of making more legible captions under the photos, or that it would be connected with the current style -
 * Under which pictures -Buni (talk) 22:33, 30 January 2023 (UTC)


 * I propose [[File:Local.png]] Localism. It is highly relevant globally (including having a Wikipedia article), sometimes mentioned in other articles (such as Urbism, Alter-Globalization, Distributism, and of course Federalism, as well as many others) and would have a variant (Regionalism), both of which are central influences to Federalism, as well as several other ideologies. The page already exists on PCBA in a well-developed form and would thus only have to be ported and minimally re-written. Also I have been told by oRange, many months ago now, that this addition was considered, though I haven't heard back from that so it might've gone under. Furthermore, I think this ideology has some use-cases in PCB comics, being able to represent local politicians, policies, and patriotism. -JonahF2014 (talk) 18:10, 27 January 2023 (UTC)
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - hiiii jonah, buni is gonna propose it dont worry about it ;)


 * Can we make colonialism and Imperialism separate pages? I think there is enough differences between the two to justify this. - YellingYowie
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - no. that is really really stupid, and is just gonna make both pages even worse, just because you are imperialist doesn't mean you can clean the image of imperialism up.
 * Hi Jao. I'm just saying if Anarcho-Naturism gets to have its page (which is totally okay btw, I mean it's the political balls wiki) then why doesn't something more well-known and more relevant get to have its own page? I assure you there is no ideological bias here, I just wish to have this clarified. - YellingYowie
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - the wiki isn't about 1 to 1 representation of reality, but rather showing off interesting political concepts while still being useful for comics, colonialism and imperialism simply play a role too similar both in policy and comics to be its own page, you can make a section about it in the imperialism page, or just propose it as a variant, but I doubt it would go through the council.


 * Australian here: Since earlier the third rule in vandalism exists; I propose that the australian liberal party should be Conservatism or Liberal Conservatism in links, The liberal party is very dense in ideologies so there are probably some Conservative Liberals but most members are Conservative, Liberal Conservative, or Fiscal Conservative; This is more of an issue as Scott Morrison is Neoconservative; A better term for him would definitely be liberal conservative, Also Pauline Hansons one nation should be One-Nation Conservative (And also given something in variants or School Of Thought to distinguish it from british versions as Greens also got a school of thought of environmentalism, And hansonism has a wikipedia page so that’s just a tiny bit more influential)
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - if edit wars are a problem we will intervene, but in edits like this I recommend just editing the page yourself.


 * — remake eye of [[File:Ingsocf.png]] Ingsoc to [[File:Pinkerton.png]] Pinkerton eye?
 * Great Idea I'm gonna put it into the council -Buni (talk) 07:00, 30 January 2023 (UTC)


 * [[File:MLL.png]] CynicalLibra - add Platonism as a separate ideology from Noocracy? also add Slave Economy as an ideology?
 * Funny but sad thing is I was actually in favor of the latter change but the council voted against it and wanted to make slave economy a variant of caste system. About Platonism sorry but no this is the political compass ball wiki not the philosophy ball wiki (a project I eventually wanna start but don't have the time due to the fact I am busy with this wiki) expect it to exist in like more than half a year -Buni (talk) 07:00, 30 January 2023 (UTC)


 * Am m - Recommend to add Internationalism and Communism as they are distinct ideological theories.
 * I like the idea of adding Internationalism but adding communism would just end in a insane amount of edit wars so no on that but I'll put internationalism into the council as a suggestion -Buni (talk) 07:00, 30 January 2023 (UTC)


 * I have few proposals for new ideologies. Slave economy and abolitionism, like, slavery and resistance to it was very important part of entire history. Also Sanationism for being extremely important to polish history and it differs from regular social authoritarianism. Russian nihilism, because many of members of this movements wasn't anarchists (nechayev or chernyshevski) or individualist anarchists (bakunin). Other important russian ideologies are menshevism and white movement. Also voluntarism is older than rothbardian ancap and it should be added. Individualism page should be added as important philosophy. Post-civ anarchism as it differs from post leftism. Degrowth instead of decelerationism because at least it's real ideology. Evolan superfascism because esoteric fascism is just tno/himmler shitpost. That's it, but i also have more ideological proposals.
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - finally a half decent comment, slavery will soon be added as a variant under the caste system, and we will eventually phase out the himmler larp from being the main thing in the esoteric fascism page. on the top of sanation and russian nihilism, many council members are interested in representing it further, but as movements they will not be their unique pages, they might appear in future pages, such as proposed revolutionary nationalism pages, but in so far, they are in a limbo state. Individualism and degrowth are simply too broad to be their own pages, tho i will propose individualism as that could be an interesting argument. also i forgot in the first edit, but the white movement and the menshevism arent substantially separated from their contemporaries or well defined enough in the case of the white movement to matter, post civilization is a great proposal, and voluntarism is already becoming a variant.
 * 1. bad idea, caste system is system of government, slave economy is system of economy 2. i think that superfascism deserves separate page. 3. adding them as page is good idea i guess, like russian nihilism and modern anarcho nihilism are fundamentally different, and if there is national democracy sanation also should be. 4. ideologies like authoritarianism, socialism, nationalism ect also are very broad but has their page.
 * There is entire page for Bakunin. Duck-Citizen (talk) 11:17, 30 January 2023 (UTC)
 * I know but russian nihilism deserves separate page from both.

Please do something about Reactionary Liberalism, maybe allow it to be a joke page(I would be willing to help) or delete it(though that doesn't seem like a great idea) - (talk).
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - sure bestie


 * Am m - Please add Pacifism, as I hate seeing links for pacifist parties/individuals lead to anarcho-pacifism instead even if they aren't anarchist. Also design idea: make Counter-Enlightenment's eyes black.
 * [[File:Jao_council.png]] jao - horrible proposal, counter enlightenment is already voted to be gone and just replace the bad redirects to stuff like humanism.